Research integrity
Flag a paper or image for review
If you have found a published paper or figure that looks wrong — a reused image panel, numbers that cannot add up, text that reads like it came from a paper mill — you can send it here.
A flag is not a finding. Screening tells people where to look; only careful human judgment turns a flag into a correction.
Send a report
Your report comes to KW Norton privately. Nothing you send here is published on the site, and your name and email are never shown.
Sources on screening
What the record shows about how flagged papers are found, by people and by software. Checked on 10 November 2026 for Fraud and Corruption Are So Everywhere.
What one person screening by eye has found
What machine screening is now flagging
What journals see when they add the software
What still takes people
- Van Noorden, "More than 10,000 research papers were retracted in 2023 — a new record," Nature, 12 December 2023
- "Hindawi reveals process for retracting more than 8,000 paper mill articles," Retraction Watch, 19 December 2023
- Rapid response, "Positive predictive values are sensitive to specificity," The BMJ
- Hosseini & Resnik, "Guidance needed for using artificial intelligence to screen journal submissions for misconduct," Research Ethics, 2024
If you also want the record corrected
The journal's editor and the publisher's research-integrity office are the people who can correct or retract a paper. These are the established places to look and to report:
Comments
Comments here are public. Talk about methods, tools and what screening can and cannot show. Please send the details of a particular paper through the private form above, and do not accuse named people in public comments.
Loading conversation…
Sign in to join the conversation.